Write a 750-1000 word analysis of “Case Study: Fetal Abnormality.” Be sure to address the following questions:Which theory or theories are being used by Jessica, Marco, Maria, and Dr. Wilson to determ Nursing Assignment Help

Write a 750-1000 word analysis of “Case Study: Fetal Abnormality.” Be sure to address the following questions:

  1. Which theory or theories are being used by Jessica, Marco, Maria, and Dr. Wilson to determine the moral status of the fetus? Explain.
  2. How does the theory determine or influence each of their recommendation for action?
  3. What theory do you agree with? How would that theory determine or influence the recommendation for action?

Prepare this assignment according to the guidelines found in the APA Style Guide

Expert Solution Preview

Introduction:
In the case study “Fetal Abnormality,” Jessica and Marco are expecting their first child, but the prenatal diagnosis indicates that the fetus has Down syndrome and a heart condition. The couple is faced with a moral dilemma as they consider their options. Dr. Wilson, the attending physician, and Maria, a medical student, also play significant roles in determining the moral status of the fetus and recommending a course of action. This analysis will examine the theories used by Jessica, Marco, Maria, and Dr. Wilson to determine the moral status of the fetus and how these theories influence their recommendations. Additionally, it will present my personal stance on the matter and how that theory would influence the recommendation for action.

1. The theories used by Jessica, Marco, Maria, and Dr. Wilson to determine the moral status of the fetus:
a. Jessica: Jessica expresses her belief that the fetus has already become a person, attributing emotional and relational qualities to it. She adopts a Deontological perspective by considering the intrinsic value of the fetus as a unique individual, irrespective of the potential challenges it may face.

b. Marco: Marco, on the other hand, takes a Utilitarian approach. He weighs the consequences of their decision on the overall happiness and well-being of their family, including the potential impact on their ability to provide for the child’s needs, as well as the happiness of their future child.

c. Maria: Maria shows indications of adopting a Virtue Ethics stance. She emphasizes the importance of expressing compassion and empathy towards the fetus, arguing that doing so aligns with her moral virtues and character.

d. Dr. Wilson: Dr. Wilson’s stance is more aligned with a Utilitarian perspective. He believes that terminating the pregnancy would prevent potential suffering for both the child and the parents. His primary concern is to promote the greatest good for the greatest number of people involved.

2. How the theories determine or influence recommendations for action:
a. Jessica: Jessica’s belief in the fetus’s personhood and the intrinsic value of life leads her to oppose terminating the pregnancy. Her Deontological perspective encourages her to prioritize the moral duty of preserving human life, regardless of the difficulties that may arise.

b. Marco: Marco’s Utilitarian approach leads him to consider the potential challenges that raising a child with Down syndrome and a heart condition may bring to their family. He contemplates the overall happiness and well-being of their family, and based on that, he suggests terminating the pregnancy to avoid potential hardships.

c. Maria: Maria’s Virtue Ethics perspective compels her to emphasize compassion and empathy. She believes that advocating for the well-being and quality of life for the child aligns with her moral virtues. She opposes terminating the pregnancy, as it goes against her deeply held values.

d. Dr. Wilson: Dr. Wilson’s Utilitarian standpoint shapes his recommendation for action. He believes that terminating the pregnancy would prevent potential suffering for both the child and the parents. His primary concern is to promote the overall happiness and well-being of the greatest number of people involved.

3. My agreement with a particular theory and its influence on the recommendation for action:
Personally, I find myself aligning more with the Deontological perspective presented by Jessica. I believe that every individual possesses inherent dignity and worth. This includes individuals who may have disabilities or face challenging circumstances. Taking this theory into account, my recommendation for action would be to offer support and resources to Jessica and Marco, enabling them to navigate the challenges that lie ahead. It would involve providing them with detailed information on available medical interventions and support networks that can help them provide the best possible care for their child.

Conclusion:
In the case study “Fetal Abnormality,” various moral theories are used by the characters to determine the moral status of the fetus and influence their recommendations for action. Jessica adopts a Deontological perspective, Marco follows a Utilitarian approach, Maria reflects Virtue Ethics, and Dr. Wilson also leans towards Utilitarianism. Each theory plays a significant role in shaping their respective recommendations. Personally, I agree with the Deontological stance held by Jessica, prioritizing the intrinsic value and dignity of the fetus. This aligns with my belief in the importance of upholding human life while providing essential support to parents facing challenging situations.

Share This Post

Email
WhatsApp
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Pinterest
Reddit

Order a Similar Paper and get 15% Discount on your First Order

Related Questions

Aubre R. presents as a new patient to your practice having Nursing Assignment Help

Aubre R. presents as a new patient to your practice having recently relocated from rural Tennessee. She is 68 years old and complains of irritable bowel syndrome (IBS) with abdominal cramping and frequent diarrhea with occasional constipation. She has a history of domestic violence with resultant anxiety requiring inpatient hospitalization

Aubre R. presents as a new patient to your practice having Nursing Assignment Help

Aubre R. presents as a new patient to your practice having recently relocated from rural Tennessee. She is 68 years old and complains of irritable bowel syndrome (IBS) with abdominal cramping and frequent diarrhea with occasional constipation. She has a history of domestic violence with resultant anxiety requiring inpatient hospitalization

Walden University, LLC. (Producer). (2019b). Alzheimer’s Nursing Assignment Help

To Prepare  Review the interactive media piece for Alzheimer’s Disease.  (76 Year Old Iranian Male) Reflect on the patient’s symptoms and aspects of the disorder presented in the interactive media piece. Consider how you might assess and treat patients presenting with the symptoms of the patient case study you were assigned. You

To Prepare Review the interactive media piece for Nursing Assignment Help

To Prepare  Review the interactive media piece for Alzheimer’s Disease.  (76 Year Old Iranian Male) Reflect on the patient’s symptoms and aspects of the disorder presented in the interactive media piece. Consider how you might assess and treat patients presenting with the symptoms of the patient case study you were assigned. You

Students are required to maintain weekly reflective Nursing Assignment Help

Students are required to maintain weekly reflective narratives throughout the course to combine into one course-long reflective journal that integrates leadership and inquiry into current practice as it applies to the Professional Capstone and Practicum course. In your journal, you will reflect on the personal knowledge and skills gained throughout

Please respond to one discussion post. Compare your Nursing Assignment Help

Please respond to one discussion post. Compare your experience with the Active Verbs activity with that of your peer. Was their experience with the activity similar to yours? If they had similar experiences with the questions, discuss why you think you had similar outcomes. If they had different experiences with

1. Read: Discussion Background This week you are learning Nursing Assignment Help

1. Read: Discussion Background  This week you are learning about codes for services and procedures assigned from the Medicine Section. As you work on assigning codes for services performed from the Medicine Section, reflect on the purpose and meaning of the guidelines found throughout this section.  2. Initial Post: Create a new